Jimmy Kimmel turned the tables on crushable heartthrob Zac Efron by asking him who he crushed on growing up. Zac spilled that he had a poster featuring a certain famous supermodel-turned-talk-show-host plastered on his wall as kid, but the young lady that really caught his eye growing up was his babysitter. Zac clearly went for the older women back in the day, as his babysitter Brooke was in college when he fell for her in third and fourth grade. And Zac may still have a chance with his childhood crush — since he said she still writes him handwritten letters to this day. Watch the super cute clip now!