Don't get us wrong: we love American Horror Story [1]. And yet, while there has certainly been no shortage of fun, quotable moments on the show [2], we've witnessed plenty of messed-up moments to match. Roanoke, of course, was no exception. In fact, with everything from horrifying crooked nurses [3] to multiple Evan Peters deaths [4], it might be one of the most messed-up seasons yet. But season six isn't the only installment to make us feel so disturbed. This has been happening since season one.
When the Pig Man Shows Up in Roanoke
When It's Literally Just Raining Human Teeth
When One of Those Evil Nurses Gags a Patient With a Soiled Diaper
When Evan Peters Gets Impaled and Lit on Fire
When Cricket Gets Disemboweled by the Butcher
When Evan Peters Is Alive Again, but Then He Gets Murdered Again
When Return to Roanoke Happens and All the Ghosts Are Real
When the Polks Tie Up Lee and Start Taking Pieces of Her Leg
When the Real Butcher Is 1,000x Scarier Than the Fake Butcher
When Shelby and Dominic Go Into the Tunnel and the Chen Family Is Climbing on the Walls
When Shelby Catches Matt With Scáthach and Beats His Brains In
When Mama Polk Yanks a Tooth Out of Audrey's Mouth
When Shelby Literally Just Kills Herself
When Monet Falls Off the Balcony and Gets Impaled on a Spike
When Lee Encounters Scathach and Eats a Pig Heart
When Everyone Dies Except For Audrey, but Then Audrey Gets Shot Down by the Police
When Matt Gets Locked Out of the Bathroom and the Pigman Slices Him to Death
When the Amateur Ghosthunters Show Up and They Get Impaled on Stakes and Lit on Fire
When That Polk Kid Busts Into Lee's Interview and Shoots Everyone
In Hotel, When the First Monster Comes Out of the Mattress
When Tristan Bites Into That Maggot-Infested Sandwich
When Gabriel Is Raped by That Fleshy Thing With a Conical Dildo
When Sally Sews Gabriel Into the Mattress
When the Countess Slashes Tristan's Throat
When We Meet the Countess's Baby, Bartholomew
When John Realizes He's the Killer
When Sally Digs the Bullets Out of the Countess
When Sally Gnashes Her Own Teeth Out
When We See That Couple Impaled and Precariously Glued Together
When Cordelia Stabs Her Eyes Out
When Stanley Cuts Off Both of Jimmy's Lobster Hands
When Chester Creb Murders his Wife and Her Lover and Blames It on His Puppet
When Twisty Stabs That Man by the Lake a Bunch of Times
When Jimmy Pleasures the Housewives With His Claw Hand
When Penny the Candy-Striper Gets Drugged and Raped, on Film
When We See What's Underneath Twisty's Mask
When We See the Back of Edward Mordrake's Head
When Elsa's Legs Get Chainsawed Off in That Flashback
When Dandy Makes His First Kill by Slitting Dora's Neck
When Dandy Stabs Andy Numerous Times and Dismembers Him
When We Find Out Zoe Has a Deadly Vagina
When We See Madame LaLaurie's Attic of Horrors For the First Time
When Spalding Cuts His Own Tongue Off
When Madame LaLaurie Makes a Human Into a Minotaur
When Basically Everyone Is Giving Themselves Blood Facials
When Madison and Zoe Assemble a Bunch of Body Parts to Make a Frankenstein Boy
When Queenie Tries to Seduce the Minotaur
When Kyle's Mom Molests Him
When Luke's Mother Gives Him a Bleach Enema
When the Severed Minotaur Head Winks
When the Countess and Donovan Have an Insane Blood Orgy
When Myrtle Snow Melon-Balls the Eyes of Her Companions
When Adam Levine's Character Gets His Arm Ripped Off
The First Time You Lay Eyes on Bloody Face
When Dr. Arden Mutilates and Dismembers Shelley
When Dr. Thredson Tries to "Cure" Lana's Homosexuality With Aversion Therapy
When Bloody Face's Son Participates in Adult Breastfeeding
When Dr. Arden Gives Anne Frank a Lobotomy
When Lana Attempts a Coat-Hanger Abortion
When Dr. Thredson Rapes Lana and Calls Her "Mommy"
When Multiple Asylum Patients Are Subjected to Electroshock Therapy
When You Realize All of Dr. Thredson's Furniture Is Made of Human Skin
When Vivien Harmon Gives Birth to the Antichrist
When You Meet the Horrifying Baby in the Basement
When Moira Bites Off That Businessman's Penis
When You See Beau, the Mutated Person in the Attic
When Dr. Harmon Is Crying and Masturbating
When You See Violet's Fly-Ridden Corpse
When the Rubber Man Rapes Vivien Harmon
Did We Get 'Em All?
