Don't get us wrong: we love American Horror Story. And yet, while there has certainly been no shortage of fun, quotable moments on the show, we've witnessed plenty of messed-up moments to match. Roanoke, of course, was no exception. In fact, with everything from horrifying crooked nurses to multiple Evan Peters deaths, it might be one of the most messed-up seasons yet. But season six isn't the only installment to make us feel so disturbed. This has been happening since season one.