Most Shocking Moments on American Horror Story
60+ Times American Horror Story Scarred You For Life
Image Source: FX
Don't get us wrong: we love American Horror Story. And yet, while there has certainly been no shortage of fun, quotable moments on the show, we've witnessed plenty of messed-up moments to match. Roanoke, of course, was no exception. In fact, with everything from horrifying crooked nurses to multiple Evan Peters deaths, it might be one of the most messed-up seasons yet. But season six isn't the only installment to make us feel so disturbed. This has been happening since season one.
1 When the Pig Man Shows Up in Roanoke
Image Source: The Weinstein Company
2 When It's Literally Just Raining Human Teeth
Image Source: ABC
3 When One of Those Evil Nurses Gags a Patient With a Soiled Diaper
Image Source: Fox
4 When Evan Peters Gets Impaled and Lit on Fire
Image Source: Lionsgate
5 When Cricket Gets Disemboweled by the Butcher
Image Source: ABC
6 When Evan Peters Is Alive Again, but Then He Gets Murdered Again
Image Source: FX
7 When Return to Roanoke Happens and All the Ghosts Are Real
Image Source: The CW
8 When the Polks Tie Up Lee and Start Taking Pieces of Her Leg
Image Source: ABC
9 When the Real Butcher Is 1,000x Scarier Than the Fake Butcher
Image Source: Warner Bros.
10 When Shelby and Dominic Go Into the Tunnel and the Chen Family Is Climbing on the Walls
Image Source: AMC
11 When Shelby Catches Matt With Scáthach and Beats His Brains In
Image Source: NBC
12 When Mama Polk Yanks a Tooth Out of Audrey's Mouth
Image Source: Columbia Pictures
13 When Shelby Literally Just Kills Herself
Image Source: NBC
14 When Monet Falls Off the Balcony and Gets Impaled on a Spike
Image Source: The CW
15 When Lee Encounters Scathach and Eats a Pig Heart
Image Source: Fox
16 When Everyone Dies Except For Audrey, but Then Audrey Gets Shot Down by the Police
Image Source: MGM
17 When Matt Gets Locked Out of the Bathroom and the Pigman Slices Him to Death
Image Source: HBO
18 When the Amateur Ghosthunters Show Up and They Get Impaled on Stakes and Lit on Fire
Image Source: Fox
19 When That Polk Kid Busts Into Lee's Interview and Shoots Everyone
Image Source: AMC
20 In Hotel, When the First Monster Comes Out of the Mattress
Image Source: Warner Bros.
21 When Tristan Bites Into That Maggot-Infested Sandwich
Image Source: Disney
22 When Gabriel Is Raped by That Fleshy Thing With a Conical Dildo
Image Source: Fox
23 When Sally Sews Gabriel Into the Mattress
Image Source: Warner Bros.
24 When the Countess Slashes Tristan's Throat
Image Source: CBS
25 When We Meet the Countess's Baby, Bartholomew
Image Source: NBC
26 When John Realizes He's the Killer
Image Source: CBS
27 When Sally Digs the Bullets Out of the Countess
Image Source: NBC
28 When Sally Gnashes Her Own Teeth Out
Image Source: Comedy Central
29 When We See That Couple Impaled and Precariously Glued Together
Image Source: Fox
30 When Cordelia Stabs Her Eyes Out
Image Source: Warner Bros.
31 When Stanley Cuts Off Both of Jimmy's Lobster Hands
Image Source: Warner Bros.
32 When Chester Creb Murders his Wife and Her Lover and Blames It on His Puppet
Image Source: NBC
33 When Twisty Stabs That Man by the Lake a Bunch of Times
Image Source: ABC
34 When Jimmy Pleasures the Housewives With His Claw Hand
Image Source: Fox
35 When Penny the Candy-Striper Gets Drugged and Raped, on Film
Image Source: Logo
36 When We See What's Underneath Twisty's Mask
Image Source: ITV
37 When We See the Back of Edward Mordrake's Head
Image Source: ABC
38 When Elsa's Legs Get Chainsawed Off in That Flashback
Image Source: MTV
39 When Dandy Makes His First Kill by Slitting Dora's Neck
Image Source: Warner Bros.
40 When Dandy Stabs Andy Numerous Times and Dismembers Him
Image Source: HBO
41 When We Find Out Zoe Has a Deadly Vagina
Image Source: Paramount Pictures
42 When We See Madame LaLaurie's Attic of Horrors For the First Time
Image Source: NBC
43 When Spalding Cuts His Own Tongue Off
Image Source: Disney
44 When Madame LaLaurie Makes a Human Into a Minotaur
Image Source: Disney
45 When Basically Everyone Is Giving Themselves Blood Facials
Image Source: Universal Pictures
46 When Madison and Zoe Assemble a Bunch of Body Parts to Make a Frankenstein Boy
Image Source: Disney
47 When Queenie Tries to Seduce the Minotaur
Image Source: NBC
48 When Kyle's Mom Molests Him
Image Source: USA
49 When Luke's Mother Gives Him a Bleach Enema
Image Source: ABC
50 When the Severed Minotaur Head Winks
Image Source: CBS
51 When the Countess and Donovan Have an Insane Blood Orgy
Image Source: Universal Pictures
52 When Myrtle Snow Melon-Balls the Eyes of Her Companions
Image Source: The CW
53 When Adam Levine's Character Gets His Arm Ripped Off
Image Source: HBO
54 The First Time You Lay Eyes on Bloody Face
Image Source: Paramount Pictures
55 When Dr. Arden Mutilates and Dismembers Shelley
Image Source: AMC
56 When Dr. Thredson Tries to "Cure" Lana's Homosexuality With Aversion Therapy
Image Source: The CW
57 When Bloody Face's Son Participates in Adult Breastfeeding
Image Source: MTV
58 When Dr. Arden Gives Anne Frank a Lobotomy
Image Source: Nickelodeon
59 When Lana Attempts a Coat-Hanger Abortion
Image Source: CBS
60 When Dr. Thredson Rapes Lana and Calls Her "Mommy"
Image Source: HBO
61 When Multiple Asylum Patients Are Subjected to Electroshock Therapy
Image Source: Fox
62 When You Realize All of Dr. Thredson's Furniture Is Made of Human Skin
Image Source: 20th Century Studios
63 When Vivien Harmon Gives Birth to the Antichrist
Image Source: CBS
64 When You Meet the Horrifying Baby in the Basement
Image Source: Universal Pictures
65 When Moira Bites Off That Businessman's Penis
Image Source: NBC
66 When You See Beau, the Mutated Person in the Attic
Image Source: Disney
67 When Dr. Harmon Is Crying and Masturbating
Image Source: NBC
68 When You See Violet's Fly-Ridden Corpse
Image Source: Disney
69 When the Rubber Man Rapes Vivien Harmon
Image Source: Bravo
Did We Get 'Em All?
Image Source: FX
