When it comes to Halloween [1], Maksim Chmerkovskiy and Peta Murgatroyd are masters of disguise. The Dancing With the Stars [2] couple, who tied the knot this Summer [3] and are parents to son Shia, 9 months, are total pros when it comes to dressing up for Oct. 31. From sexy outfits to over-the-top makeup, these two certainly go above and beyond [4]. Plus, it seems like they have a soft spot for fairy tales — Peta has dressed up as a storybook character on more than one occasion. See their best looks over the years ahead.