You would think that American Horror Story [1] veteran Sarah Paulson is used to getting scared by now, but she still lets out that infamous blood-curdling scream when caught off guard. The actress stopped by The Ellen DeGeneres Show [2] on Tuesday to chat about the new season of the hit show, but the host, as always, had a few more tricks up her sleeve. After scaring Sarah by hiding in the closet in her dressing room, Ellen had a man creep up behind her during their interview. But the best part came when a creepy clown, which is a major theme in this season's Cult [3], popped out of the coffee table. Sarah was so scared that she fell to the floor and grabbed Ellen's legs before hiding under the table. Same, Sarah. Same.