Friends [1]: a classic, quotable comedy [2] about six NYC-based pals, or the vivid dreams of a woman on the edge? Apparently a lot of people seem to think it's the latter, all because of a seemingly innocuous photo on the season four DVD box set. In July, Twitter user Ted Fox [3] shared the image, asking his followers why Rachel Green (Jennifer Aniston) is the only one in it with her eyes open, while the rest of the characters sleep soundly beside her.

Serious question:

Why is Rachel the only one 👀?

Theories needed. #FriendsGate [4] pic.twitter.com/QOlQcDtaGL [5]

— Ted Fox (@thetedfox) July 7, 2017 [6]

It didn't take long before people started responding with possible theories, leading to what will now be known as #Friendsgate.

There were serious discussions about all 10 seasons being a dream . . .

Here is what I believe Friends is really about. pic.twitter.com/hziUHAKVVX [7]

— Phil Dunne (@lovetherobot) July 7, 2017 [8]

And some jokes at Chandler's expense (duh) . . .

Chandler is spooning her. The answer is obvious.

— Terry Bain (@terrybain) July 7, 2017 [9]

A reference to the gang's mysterious lack of rent was made . . .

She alone knows the truth. She has seen beyond the veil, and knows that there is no way she should be able to afford that apartment

— Woodstock's dad (@Burghpunk) July 7, 2017 [10]

And of course someone had to point out that they all might be dead . . .

they were dead the entire time any ways have a great weekend https://t.co/e47hcyan4P [11]

— darth:™ (@darth) July 7, 2017 [12]

Until, finally, someone pointed out the whole discussion was just a "moo point."

Serious answer: The fact that her eyes are open is just a moo point. pic.twitter.com/80L8OnRoVI [13]

— Gabrielle Birkman (@GabbyBirkman) July 7, 2017 [14]

Honestly, I didn't think that insane theory about Ross losing custody of Ben [15] could be topped, but this might just take the cake.