There's a reason Jamie Dornan is everyone's favorite Irishman, no matter how many creepy hotties he plays. After small roles in films and on TV (like Once Upon a Time [1]), Dornan scored his breakout part on the Irish crime drama The Fall. If you've watched any of the two seasons on Netflix [2], you know that he plays Paul Spector, a dedicated family man who happens to get his rocks off by brutalizing young women at night. After he was selected to play Christian Grey in Fifty Shades of Grey [3], we found out that while his character may have some kinks, he's no killer. Still, both Paul and Christian manage to be heart-stoppingly sexy, despite being borderline disturbing — full-on disturbing, in Paul's case. In honor Fifty Shades Freed [4], here are all the times Dornan's characters are both somewhat terrifying and ridiculously hot at the same time. Pro tip: you can tell them apart because Christian is clean-shaven and Paul has a beard.

When Christian Grey Walks Around Without a Shirt and With an Attitude

When Paul Spector Answers the Door Without a Shirt and Ready to Rumble

When Christian Grabs Ana's Face Slightly Too Intensely

When Paul Creepily Talks to an Underage Schoolgirl

When Christian Selects His Mask of Choice

When Paul Takes Off His Mask of Choice . . . For Murdering

When Christian Stares So Intently You're Almost Uncomfortable

When Paul Stares So Intently That the Table Is Uncomfortable

When Christian Looks Ominous Even While Primping

When Paul Does These Sinister Pull-Ups

When Christian Tries Vanilla Sex but Is All, "Ugh, I'm Bored"

When Paul Participates in Family Life but Can't Even Deal

When Christian's Pensive Pose Is Kind of Menacing

When Paul Puts His Thinking Cap On . . . About How to Murder Better

When Christian Engages in Some Very Frank Sexy Talk

When Paul Doesn't Trust Himself (Because He's a Murderer)

When Christian Manages to Look Eerie Even While Just Standing

When Paul Sees Christian's Creepiness and Raises Him by 100

When Christian's Eyes Terrify and Excite You to Your Very Core

When You Get Lost in Paul's Dreamy/Nightmarish Eyes

When Christian Gets Up Close and Personal

When Paul Gets Too Close For Comfort and Also Safety

When Christian Is So Scary-Hot That You're Not Sure What to Do With Your Feelings

When Paul Redefines Sexiness but Is Also a Cold-Blooded Killer

When Christian Looks Like He Might Murder His Piano

When Paul Actually Does Murder Humans

When Christian Has That Fire Behind His Eyes

When Paul Takes His Shirt Off (Again) and You Need a Glass of Water

When Christian Gets All Serious

When Paul Says Words

When Christian Cozies Up to His Lady

When Paul Stands Behind the Detective Who Is Trying to Charge Him With Murder

When Christian Partakes in Some Foreplay

When Paul Takes Off His Shirt in Preparation For Homicide

When Christian Burns a Hole in His Windshield (With His Eyes)

When Paul Just Straight-Up Breaks Into a Car

When Christian Forcibly Takes Ana's Head Into His Hands

When Paul Is Forcibly Put Into a Police Car

When Christian Carries Ana Down the Hall

When Paul Looks Over His Sexy, Murdery Shoulder

When Christian Stalks Ana Because He Likes Her

When Paul Stalks His Victims Because He Wants to Kill Them