Well, it's official, Bachelor Nation. A decision for the next season of The Bachelor has finally been made [1], and the new leading man will be . . . Arie Luyendyk Jr. Although many fans were expecting Peter Kraus [2] or Wells Adams [3] to be crowned the next Bachelor, the title unexpectedly went to the 35-year-old race car driver, who was the runner-up on Emily Maynard's season of The Bachelorette [4] back in 2012. Even though there's been some excitement over ABC's unexpected choice (including some kind words from fellow Bachelorette alum Evan Bass [5]), most people on Twitter seem to be asking the same question: "Um, who is Arie Lyendyk Jr., again? [6]" We've gone ahead and rounded up the most hilarious reactions to the announcement, so check them out ahead.