The Mandalorian [1] introduced a new guest star that has the internet buzzing: Amy Sedaris appears in the fifth episode as Peli Motto, a mechanic who winds up being totally charmed by Baby Yoda [2] when the creature and its Mandalorian protector [3] stop on Tatooine. The unexpected cameo [4] comes in an episode that also includes a guest appearance from Agents of S.H.I.E.L.D.'s Ming-Na Wen, and it has fans everywhere talking [5]. While Sedaris was probably not on the list of actors anyone expected to show up, her near-unrecognizable turn in this episode already has fans hoping she'll be back. Ahead, check out some of the best reactions on Twitter to Sedaris's guest spot — do you hope she'll return for another episode?