Chocolate Peanut Butter Pie Oreos have officially arrived, and we just might prefer these over a real slice! This wild new flavor was first reported last year, and it's finally on shelves now. The Oreos have a peanut butter- and chocolate-flavored creme sandwiched between two graham-flavored cookies, acting as the crust, so if you live for the combination of chocolate and PB, you definitely need these in your life. Picking up a package of these cookies is way easier than making your own peanut butter pie [1], right? In addition to that new flavor, Pistachio Oreo Thins are available in stores now, so add these to your list of new snacks [2] to try.