Fall is my favorite time of year — not only because I can justify my unending love for horror movies, turtleneck sweaters, apple cider, and pumpkin pie, but because it's time for me to host seasonal candle sniffathons [1] here at POPSUGAR HQ. As soon as I saw that Bath & Body Works had released its slate of autumnal candle scents [2], I reached out for samples of the brand's top Fall sellers and arranged for sniff-happy editors to give their honest reviews.
Between three of Bath & Body Works's most iconic Fall candles, our editors had a clear favorite. Check out their honest takes about the brand's best seasonal scent before you stock up on candles — you may want to buy a dozen of our number one pick!
Leaves
Leaves candle [4] ($25) with notes of red apple, golden nectar, and clove spice.
We gave it:
Editor reviews:
- "Kinda in love with this! Not the most 'leaf'-smelling candle, but it reminds me of the holidays and gives a cozy vibe."
- "Wasn't sure what to expect, but pleasantly surprised. Different — in a good way! Subtle with a touch of spice."
- "I love the candle design. The scent is a little strong, but pretty."
- "Nice fragrance — doesn't smell like leaves, though."
- "Strong, like a batch of spiced cider."
Heirloom Apple
Heirloom Apple candle [5] ($25) with notes of honeycrisp apple, sugarcane, and apple blossom.
We gave it:
Editor reviews:
- "Smells like apple soap."
- "Cool packaging, but not for me."
- "I feel like this apple scent would be less strong when actually burning."
- "Smells like a teen's bedroom."
- "Kinda has a synthetic scent, but the packaging is a 10/10."
WINNER: Sweet Cinnamon Pumpkin
Sweet Cinnamon Pumpkin candle [6] ($23) with notes of pumpkin, clove, vanilla cream, and brown sugar.
We gave it:
Editor reviews:
- "I love how this candle blends Thanksgiving AND Christmas smells! A couple of these would last you through the whole holiday season."
- "Not into the packaging, but the scent is delicious. Strong enough to carry through your whole apartment."
- "Smells like my childhood Winter holiday memories! But only the good ones. The cinnamon element is gorgeous."
- "This makes me say, 'Yasss.' Cinnamon + pumpkin = ultimate Fall combo."
- "I would buy this. Great for November; just the right amount of cinnamon and pumpkin."