Ready to feel old? On Nov. 23, 2021, the iconic '90s toy Tamagotchi [1] turned 25 years old — a full-blown adult. In addition to the Tamagotchi that you may or may not have forgotten to take care of, every '90s kid has some pretty epic toys [2] stashed away from their childhood, and it may be time to dust off your old Totally Hair Barbie [3] and Polly Pocket. Some of our favorite '80s and '90s toys [4] are worth a pretty penny on eBay and Etsy today. Take a look at some of the hidden treasures you may have tucked away in a closet or garage now!
— Additional reporting by Theresa Massony
Polly Pocket
Polly Pocket 1995 Fantastic Light Fashion Show [6] ($1,400)
Totally Hair Barbie
Totally Hair Barbie 1992 [7] ($185)
Disney Perfume Princesses
1995 Disney Perfume Princess Collection Gift Set [8] ($67)
Lil Miss Magic Jewels
Lil Miss Magic Jewels 1992 [9] ($100)
Mall Madness
1996 Electronic Mall Madness [10] ($200)
Trolls
'90s The Russ Troll Collection Extra Large Troll Doll [11] ($175)
Krystal Princess Doll
Krystal Princess Doll [12] ($248)
Barbie Color Change Makeup Center
1989 Barbie Color Change Makeup Center [13] ($300)
Tamagotchi
Rare Bandai Pink Tamagotchi 1996-1997, Version 1 [14] ($1,480)
Magic Nursery Dolls
1989 Mattel Magic Nursery Doll [15] ($100)
Dream Dollhouse
1993 Fisher Price Dream Dollhouse [16] ($200)
My Pretty Ballerina
My Pretty Ballerina 1990 [17] ($97)
My Size Barbie
My Size Barbie 1992 [18] ($155)
Puffalump
1994 Puffalump Pink Bear Teddy [19] ($96)
Western Stampin' Barbie and Western Star Horse
Western Stampin' Barbie Doll and Western Star Horse Set 1993 [20] ($180)
Doodle Bear
Original Pocket Doodle Bear Juniors [21] ($55)
Popples
Pink Ballet Popples Doll [22] ($135)
Mommy's Having a Baby
Mommy's Having a Baby 1992 [23] ($70)
Beanie Babies
Rare First Edition Princess Diana Beanie Baby [24] ($57,172)
Lego Town Paradisa
Lego Town Paradisa Poolside Paradise 1992 [25] ($225)
Cupcakes Doll
Cupcakes Dolls Cutie Fruiti Suzana'nana Banana Doll [26] ($150)
Cherry Merry Muffin Dolls
1988 Cherry Merry Muffin Banancy Doll [27] ($85)
Baby Alive
Juice 'n' Cookies Baby Alive Doll 1995 [28] ($130)
American Girl Dolls
1996 Samantha American Girl Doll [29] ($2,552)
Fairy Winkles
1994 Fairy Winkles Folly Magic Kenner Toy [30] ($67)
Littlest Pet Shop
Littlest Pet Shop Mom Cat With 4 Kittens Play Set [31] ($54)
Furby
Furby Original Model Snow Leopard 1998 [32] ($390)
Baby Rollerblade
1991 Baby Rollerblade [33] ($146)
Pretty Pretty Princess
Pretty Pretty Princess Game 1999 [34] ($70)
Miss Party Surprise Doll
Big Sisters Miss Party Surprise Costume Party Doll Cathy 1999 [35] ($85)
My Little Pony
South African Heart Throb My Little Pony [36] ($2,853)
Girl Talk
1990 Girl Talk Truth or Dare Board Game [37] ($76)
Lite-Brite
Lite Brite With Pegs and Refill Sheets 1993 [38] ($154)
Secret Keepins
1994 Secret Keepins Sweetheart Pups Kenner White Pink Plush Dog Lock Charm [39] ($400)
Kitty Kitty Kittens
1995 Tyco Kitty Kitty Baby Kittens [40] ($351)
POGs
100+ pieces 1990s POGs [41] ($319)
Twinkles Doll
1990 Baby Twinkles Doll [42] ($130)
Sky Dancers
Sky Dancers Rose Blossom [43] ($85)
Quints Dolls
Quints Dolls 1989 [44] ($100)
Beauty and the Beast VHS Tape
Beauty and the Beast VHS Tape [45] ($5,000)
Super Mario Bros. 3 Nintendo 1990
Super Mario Bros. 3 Nintendo 1990 [46] ($36,000)
1996 Happy Holidays Barbie
1996 Happy Holidays Barbie [47] ($499)
Pokemon Pokedex Trainer Card
1999 Pokemon Pokedex Trainer Card [48] ($30,000)
The Baby-Sitters Club Dolls
Complete Set of The Babysitter Club Dolls [49] ($5,000)
Polly Pocket Watch
Polly Pocket Watch [50] ($351)
Polly Pocket Roller Skates
Polly Pocket Roller Skates [51] ($358)
Mr. Potato Head
Mr. Potato Head [52] ($1,650)
A Full Tamagotchi Collection
Rare Tamagotchi Lot [53] ($485)
1998 Pokémon Figures
Rare 1998 Pokémon Figure Lot [54] ($450)
Rare 1989 Tomy JOUJOU Kids Toy Food Vending Machine
Rare 1989 Tomy JOUJOU Food Vending Machine [55] ($191)
Goosebumps Shakin' Creature
Vintage '90s Goosebumps Shakin' Creature [56] ($198)
Carolyn Bennett Kaleidoscope
Vintage Carolyn Bennett Kaleidoscope [57] ($238)
Barbie Tag Along Wags Puppy
1992 Barbie Tag Along Wags Puppy [58] ($150)
Complete Set of Furby Christmas Ornaments
1999 Furby Christmas Ornaments [59] ($132)
Sesame Street Cookie Crunch Toy
Sesame Street Cookie Crunch Toy [60] ($187, originally $220)
Polly Pocket: Polly's Wonderful Wedding Party
Polly Pocket: Polly's Wonderful Wedding Party [61] ($190)
Home Pretty Barbie Doll
1990 Home Pretty Barbie Doll #2249 [62] ($75)
Tamagotchi Connection V4 Blue Sunflowers + Mametchi Gotchi Gear
Tamagotchi Connection V4 Blue Sunflowers + Mametchi Gotchi Gear [63] ($70)