Whether you're a serious makeup hoarder or just getting into beauty, you need to know this: owning one red lipstick is not enough. Even if you think you've found the perfect red, you should have varying shades of crimson for all occasions. But we get it . . . there are so many formulas out there, it's hard to sift through and find the best ones. Luckily, one Reddit user compiled a lipstick spreadsheet of fellow Redditors' favorite hues.
In honor of Valentine's Day, we've made it even easier than that! We narrowed down this list to our top picks, and then took quotes from the products' biggest fans — Sephora reviewers, Redditors, and MakeupAlley users — that prove how awesome they are. Just don't blame us if you blow your whole paycheck on red lipsticks.