If you thought lip liner was so '90s, think again, ladies! Obsessive Compulsive Cosmetics (creator of cult favorite Lip Tar) has a full range of pencils ($16) that you can use on your lips and your eyes. My favorite from the collection is perfect for Valentine's Day! It's called Anti-Feathered, an invisible liner that takes the guesswork out of matching your liner to your favorite red lipstick. And it keeps it in place all night long!