Skip Nav
Photo 6 of 9


Toby Cavanaugh

Why It Might Be Toby:

  • Let's not forget that it was Toby's house that exploded a few weeks ago. Could that have been a first attempt made by "A"?
  • "A" has been known to target the police, with victims like Detective Wilden and Garrett Reynolds.

Why He Might Be Safe:

  • Toby's been on the "A" side before and already eluded the clutches of "A" once. He's smart.
  • "A" has proven at this point that Toby isn't really a threat. He's not causing trouble, and he's not directly involved in anything in Ali's disappearance. At least that we know of.

Source: ABC Family