Everything You Need to Know About Toasted Marshmallow Milano Cookies

We prayed to the cookie gods that Toasted Marshmallow Milano Cookies would deliver on their marshmallow-y flavor promise. Spoiler alert: they do! The new cookie by Pepperidge Farm, which is available now at Target and will be available nationwide on Jan. 1 for $4 per bag, is like the classic Milano you already know, but with a layer of marshmallow-flavored icing that leaves you with a s'mores-like taste in your mouth.

POPSUGAR editors eagerly flocked to try the wintertime cookies, and there were resounding "Mmmm"s in the office. "My new favorite Milano!" one taster wrote, while another noted, "Definitely taste the marshmallow flavor. No artificial flavor, and so vanilla-y." A unanimous conclusion from everyone is that these taste reminiscent of S'mores Pop-Tarts in the best way — we're left feeling nostalgic for one of our favorite childhood treats. Once you spot Toasted Marshmallow Milanos at your nearest Target, I'd recommend grabbing a bag and simmering up a batch of red wine hot chocolate. You'll likely end up adding one more New Year's resolution to your list: eat more of these.

★★★★☆