Move Over, Nina Dobrev! Victoria Justice's Real Twin Is Her Sister, Madison

Puerto Rican actress Victoria Justice and her sister, Madison, looked more like twins at a comedy show hosted by Amy Schumer and Jerry Seinfeld to celebrate Baby Buggy's anniversary in New York City on Nov. 16. We can't help but think that the dark-haired beauties, whose resemblance is uncanny, tried to play a game of mistaken identity or the old-school twin switcheroo on all of us, showing up at the red carpet wearing almost the exact same outfit. In royal-blue dresses, black outerwear, and black boots (with their hair styled in the same way), the sisters had everyone taking a double take. Keep scrolling to see more pictures of the duo, then check out all the reasons you should be following Victoria on Snapchat.