Skip Nav
Photo 7 of 10


The Swirled-Surprise Cake

Weighing in at 12 pounds, the cake created a focal point for the party. But the cake was more than meets the eye. "The cake cutting definitely stands out as a memorable party moment," Jenny shared. "Instead of your typical white cake, I secretly colored the cake batter blue to surprise party guests with the baby's gender. We called it the 'Blue or Pink, What Do You Think?' cake. As a party activity, we passed around newborn diapers and a Sharpie. Each guest wrote a little message or something funny on a diaper. Kinda entertaining for those 3 a.m. changings!"

Source: Jenny Keller of Jenny Cookies

All the Latest From Ryan Reynolds