Then: Popular jock Mike Dexter has it all in high school — including Amanda — but he lets her go in anticipation of college girls. When an older guy tells him it's harder to get girls in college, Mike tries to win Amanda back and fails miserably in front of everyone.

Now: Facinelli has enjoyed success both in TV and film, with roles in Nurse Jackie and in the Twilight franchise, where he played Dr. Carlisle Cullen.