How to Shop Thrift Stores Like an Expert

POPSUGAR Photography | Aemilia Madden
POPSUGAR Photography | Aemilia Madden

Yes — I'm a fashion editor who buys most of her clothing secondhand. Over the years, I've managed to amass some crazy-amazing finds, and there are some days when I walk out the door only to realize not a single piece of my outfit is brand new. Currently, I am lucky enough to live in New York City, the land of opportunity, especially when it comes to shopping. With so many stylish women concentrated in one place, I know their old clothes must be going somewhere, and I'm on a hunt to find the best of their discarded duds. But even before I moved to America's chicest city, thrift shopping was my high-fashion hobby, an adrenaline rush only other style enthusiasts can understand.

My devotion to consignment shopping began as early as middle school. From the moment I scooped up my first J.Crew peacoat (which I still wear to this day), I was hooked. The realization that with a little sleuthing and some good luck I could find something exceptional for a fraction of its original price was a style awakening — and I never looked back.

As I grew older, the thrill of the find never faded, especially as my taste in clothing leaned more and more toward the unattainable. What college student can afford a $100 t-shirt? And while it wasn't often that I found a silky T by Alexander Wang gem hidden among the racks, when I did, I left the store beaming. I also grew to love the shock and awe from my friends upon discovering that I had found my treasured Prada heels at Crossroads Trading Company. And it's not just about the major designer scores; it's about finding pieces that slide on perfectly, that fit like a glove, and that make you feel excited to wear them every opportunity possible. I've had both good friends and Victoria's Secret models go wild for my $10 shearling and denim vintage Levi's jacket.

These days, my continued devotion to secondhand shopping comes from both a love of the sport and a budget-conscious lifestyle. Making it in NYC isn't always easy, and when push comes to shove, the first thing to go is new clothes. While some of my friends allot their spare funds to fast-fashion shopping from Forever 21 and H&M, I would rather snap up a single higher-priced secondhand piece that is truly something special. Yes, the quality is better, but I also feel more attached to a pair of Stella McCartney shoes than I ever would to a few trendy dresses. And while not everyone may agree with me, in my closet it's the designer pieces that stand the test of time.

I know that walking into a used-clothing store can be totally overwhelming. Racks overflow with musty Harley-Davidson t-shirts and ill-fitting bandage dresses while aggressive shoppers elbow you out of the way — I've been there too. But practice makes perfect, and with more time spent browsing, I've picked up some tricks for managing the anxiety and the chaos. Read on for six tips to help you become a successful (and satisfied) secondhand shopper (just like me!).

1. Shopping Is a Marathon, Not a Sprint

1. Shopping Is a Marathon, Not a Sprint

Instead of treating any store visit as your one opportunity to get what you need, think of the bigger picture. You are slowly building your ideal closet piece by piece, and like a fine wine, a great wardrobe just takes time.

2. Make It a Habit

2. Make It a Habit

Like shopping for groceries or dropping off dry cleaning, I have made a visit to the local thrift store part of my routine. I don't get bogged down with looking through every item; instead, I quickly go through racks waiting for something to catch my eye. That way, every visit is short and sweet since a lot of the merchandise I've seen before. It also makes it easy to spot what's new and noteworthy.

3. Don't Be Disappointed

3. Don't Be Disappointed

The majority of my shopping trips don't actually involve buying anything. While I'm always optimistic that I'll find something life-altering, if there's nothing remarkable on the racks, it's nothing but an opportunity to save my funds for my next visit. Honestly, it can be satisfying to walk out empty-handed knowing you didn't miss any amazing finds that day.

4. Don't Buy It Just Because

4. Don't Buy It Just Because

If there's one bad habit I developed through my devotion to thrift shopping, it's the "just because" buy. Especially when I was younger, I was easily wooed by beautiful shoes that almost fit or a dress that was just barely too big. "I'll wear them," I told myself after I spotted a pair of lust-worthy Phillip Lim loafers; how could I pass them up? Fast-forward to a year later, and the only time I had worn the shoes, my feet barely fit inside and I spent the day in excruciating pain — lesson learned. I finally gave up and sold the shoes again on eBay. My lesson? That even if I find things I've been looking for forever, if the shoe doesn't fit — don't buy it.

5. Make a Must-Haves List

5. Make a Must-Haves List

Just because I'm consignment shopping doesn't mean I can buy whatever I want. Even secondhand, quality clothes are expensive! When I'm being extracareful with my budget, I've learned to keep my shopping to my must-have list. Instead of perusing the entire store, I'll beeline straight for the boots or sweaters and focus on finding the piece I need. If it's not there, I will fight to ignore the rest of the store and simply call it a day.

6. Always Triple-Check

6. Always Triple-Check

When messing with the secondhand clothing market, there is always the chance that you're buying a lemon — yes, I've come home with ripped, spotted, and altered clothes. Now, I'll triple-check pieces in the mirror and inspect them up close before I walk out the door, especially since most stores don't allow returns. On occasion, I'll find a piece I love that is flawed but fixable, and I will ask about a steeper discount. When it comes to buying things used, knowledge is power.