I Tested Old Navy's Leggings, and These 3 Are at the Top of My List

Old Navy
Every editorial product is independently selected by our editors. If you buy something through our links, we may earn commission.

When it comes to shopping for workout tights, there are a number of factors to keep in mind. The first, of course, is thinking about what activity you'll be dressing for — cycling, for example, can be really uncomfortable in a pair of shorts — and then considering any other needs you'll have. I for one need pockets on my tights when I eventually go to the gym because I hate trying to balance all of my things on a weight bench when I'd rather just be hands-free. I'd heard a ton of buzz about Old Navy activewear, so I decided it was time to try out its most popular styles. See how they stacked up!

Old Navy High-Waisted Elevate Built-In Sculpt 7/8-Length Compression Leggings
oldnavy.gap.com

Old Navy High-Waisted Elevate Built-In Sculpt 7/8-Length Compression Leggings

I tested the High-Waisted Elevate Built-In Sculpt 7/8-Length Compression Leggings For Women ($45, originally $50) to see how they'd perform in a Pilates class. I have certain tights I wear for specific workouts, and I wanted something that was flattering but would move with me in even the most awkward of positions.

Best For Pilates: High-Waisted Elevate Built-In Sculpt 7/8-Length Compression Leggings
POPSUGAR Photography | Rebecca Brown

Best For Pilates: High-Waisted Elevate Built-In Sculpt 7/8-Length Compression Leggings

It was clear to me the minute I put these on that this legging was about movement much more than sweat-wicking. Boy could I move my legs! These are also incredibly snug. I was fearful that that might restrict my movement in the session, but it wasn't the case. I had all of the mobility I needed. And the best part about these leggings is that I never had to tug them up. They definitely stay in place. There are a number of things that can go wrong with your wardrobe in a Pilates at-home class, but my pet peeve would have to be accidentally wearing tights with a zipper on the back. I'm happy to report that these not only are completely zipper-free, but they felt seam-free against my skin, even while lying on my side.

Old Navy High-Waisted Elevate Powersoft 7/8-Length Side-Pocket Leggings
oldnavy.gap.com

Old Navy High-Waisted Elevate Powersoft 7/8-Length Side-Pocket Leggings

Next I tested the High-Waisted Elevate Powersoft 7/8-Length Side-Pocket Leggings For Women ($40) to see how the pair delivered when it came to pockets.

Best For Pockets: Old Navy High-Waisted Elevate Powersoft 7/8-Length Side-Pocket Leggings
POPSUGAR Photography | Rebecca Brown

Best For Pockets: Old Navy High-Waisted Elevate Powersoft 7/8-Length Side-Pocket Leggings

Side pockets are everything to me, but just because a pant has them doesn't mean they can hold up to the pressure. I'm someone who stuffs a lot into their pockets, and I almost never use waistband zippers anymore because they can barely hold anything. I wore these tights to see how much I could shove into the pockets, and whether or not anything would fall out during a long walk.

I'm happy to report that while doing legs, I managed to fit my wallet, keys, and cell phone into the pockets, enabling me to be completely hands-free during my walk. I turned things up and did a quick HIIT session and a park to really test them out. Throughout squats, lunges, and other moves, nothing budged or pushed against my skin.

POPSUGAR Photography | Rebecca Brown

Old Navy High-Waisted Run Leggings
oldnavy.gap.com

Old Navy High-Waisted Run Leggings

Lastly I tested the High-Waisted Run Leggings ($20, originally $33) for running because I'm very specific about my running tights. I need something high-rise so I never have to think about tugging my pants up, and I need to be able to move my legs freely should I get a burst of energy and want to sneak in a few sprints.

Best For Running: Old Navy High-Waisted Run Leggings
POPSUGAR Photography | Rebecca Brown

Best For Running: Old Navy High-Waisted Run Leggings

The second I put these on I knew they were meant for running. They were much firmer than the other tights I tested, but I still had full range. The waistband was considerably higher than my other running tights, and I think that's what helped them stay in place. I loved the slight sheen to them, and there are breathable mesh panels on the backside of the knee that made moving easier.