PEN15 Stars Had the Most Relatable Reaction to Meeting Y2K Teen Idol, Matthew Lawrence

Maya Erskine and Anna Konkle portray middle schoolers in their hit Hulu show, PEN15, but they actually reverted back to their teenage selves when they met their Y2K teen idol, Matthew Lawrence. During an appearance on Busy Tonight, the 31-year-old actresses were surprised by the former Boy Meets World actor. Let's be completely honest: we would have the exact same reaction if we came face-to-face with our childhood celebrity crush. After trying (and failing) to keep their cool, Matthew gave the actresses a nostalgic little gift. Watch the cute video ahead!