Skip Nav
Love It. Save Your Favorites Now.
Who Was Your First Celebrity Crush? 23 Women Reveal Who First Stole Their Heart
View On One Page
ADVERTISEMENT ()
Start Slideshow

Nobody forgets their first love. But while a lot of us know what it's like to actually be in a real relationship for the first time, our first crushes can sometimes have an even bigger impact . . . especially when it comes to celebrities. From a young Leonardo DiCaprio on Growing Pains to *NSYNC's unforgettable years to the many heartthrobs of the '90s, we young girls growing up back in the day had so many handsome guys to hang posters of on our bedroom walls.

We decided to ask our POPSUGAR colleagues about their first celebrity obsessions, and the results are both hilarious and painfully relatable. Keep reading to see who everyone daydreamed about (hint: Leo's slide is huge), then check out 74 things you totally did as a teenager in the 2000s.

Justin Timberlake
Elton John
Lance Bass
Nick Carter
Billy Ray Cyrus
Mark Owen
Zac Hanson
Val Kilmer
Tom Felton
Elijah Wood
Freddie Prinze Jr.
Shane West
Devon Sawa
Leonardo DiCaprio
Joey Lawrence
Noah Wyle
Erik von Detten
Jonathan Taylor Thomas
Mark-Paul Gosselaar
Start Slideshow
Around The Web
Is Kate Bosworth Open to Filming Another Blue Crush Movie?
Kate Bosworth
Kate Bosworth Is Down to Give Blue Crush the Sequel It Deserves: "I'd Love to Do It"
by Kelsey Garcia
These Suits From the Runway Remind Us of the Royals' Style
The Royals
Is It Just Us, or Is Royal Suiting Ruling the Runways?
by Sarah Wasilak
Girlfriends Cast Will Reunite on an Episode of Black-ish
Tracee Ellis Ross
The Girlfriends Cast Is Reuniting For a Black-ish Episode, and I've Already Set My DVR
by Mekishana Pierre
Best Home Products From Target 20th Anniversary Collection
Affordable Decor
Target's 20th Anniversary Collection Has Designer Products at Amazing Prices — Need We Say More?
by Lauren Harano
Jennifer Lopez Wears Balmain Denim at the Hustlers Screening
Jennifer Lopez
Jennifer Lopez Rocked Balmain's Version of the Canadian Tuxedo at the Hustlers Screening
by Kara Kia
Coach New York Fashion Week Show Spring 2020
Kaia Gerber
Coach's Runway Is a Trip Back to the '80s — Grab Your Leather Jacket and High-Tops
by Sarah Wasilak

From Our Partners

Now You Know

When Does One Day At a Time Season 4 Premiere?

Entertainment News

We're Back, Baby! Here's When One Day at a Time Season 4 Premieres

by Mekishana Pierre

Fashion

Rihanna Danced on Stage in Sexy Savage x Fenty Lingerie, and I’ll Never Be the Same

by Nikita Ramsinghani

Celebrity News

Felicity Huffman Will Serve 14 Days in Prison Following College Admissions Cheating Scandal

by Kelsie Gibson

Celebrity News

Michael Phelps and Nicole Johnson Are a Family of 5 — See Their Newborn Baby Boy!

by Kelsie Gibson

Entertainment News

The "Black Bonnie and Clyde" Make a Run For Freedom in the Trailer For Queen & Slim

by Mekishana Pierre

Family

This 9-Year-Old Double Amputee Just Made Her Modeling Debut at New York Fashion Week

by Danielle Jackson

Celebrity News

Cole Sprouse Celebrates Lili Reinhart's Birthday With Several PDA-Filled Snaps: "So Lucky"

by Kelsie Gibson

Family

Chance the Rapper Postponed His Tour to Help His Wife Raise Their Newborn, and What a Guy

by Victoria Messina

Latest Celebrity & Entertainment
We're Hiring! Write For Us About Us Advertising Contact FAQ Archives
Power Your Happy POPSUGAR at Kohl's Collection Beauty by POPSUGAR POPSUGAR Must Have POPSUGAR Insights
Terms Privacy Policy
©2019 PopSugar • POPSUGAR Entertainment & Culture
All the Latest From Ryan Reynolds