The American Horror Story Guys Giggle and Scream Their Way Through a Haunted House

Updated on Sep 20, 2016 at 1:30 PM

Just because American Horror Story is the scariest show around, it doesn't mean the cast can't let loose. Last Friday, Evan Peters, Denis O'Hare, and Finn Wittrock stopped by Universal Studios Hollywood to kick off Halloween Horror Nights. Of course, the group had to check out the AHS-themed haunted house, which highlighted many terrifying moments from the show's previous seasons. And, well, let's just say they had trouble holding it together. We've collected our favorite pictures and captioned them with the likely thoughts of each star.

Denis O'Hare: "Ah, yes. Now I can finally be myself."

Finn Wittrock: "I should not have done this."
Evan Peters: "Nope."
Guy in the Background: "Holy sh*t, can I have a selfie?"

Denis O'Hare: "I'm just saying, I thought it would be scarier."
Finn Wittrock: "This looks just like my teddy bear!"

Evan Peters: [Screaming]
Denis O'Hare: "Oh sh*t! LOL!"
Finn Wittrock: "Release me from this prison."

Finn Wittrock: [Squealing]
Evan Peters: "Yikes, though."
Denis O'Hare: "What is that, Knotty Pine?"

Evan Peters: [Shrieking]
Finn Wittrock: "JungleJim4322@yahoo.com? Is that you?"
Denis O'Hare: "This is cute, but where's the exit?"

Finn Wittrock: "PLEASE DON'T EAT ME."
Denis O'Hare: "Oh nooo."
Evan Peters: "Bruh."

Denis O'Hare: "I will slap you."
Twisty: "OMG no, please, I was just kidding. Have mercy?"

Denis O'Hare: "Oh hey, long time!"
Evan Peters: "How you been? Miss you."
Finn Wittrock: "Who even is this?"

Denis O'Hare: "Oh man, what a gas."
Finn Wittrock: "Please just let it end."

Finn Wittrock: "Man, am I glad that's over. So many heart attacks."
Denis O'Hare: "Oh, don't be so dramatic."
Evan Peters: "Um, you had a heart attack?"

Finn Wittrock: "Never again."
Denis O'Hare: "Aw, c'mon. It was great."
Evan Peters: "I miss that rubber suit."