Hand-picked, single-estate grown, reserve — No we aren't talking about wine. Premium olive oils are making their way into the market, and our new obsession is Lucini Founders Reserve Olive Oil ($40). In the November 2013 batch, picked and pressed in Tuscany, only 5,000 bottles were made. Such care and attention goes into every bottle, and the robust, peppery flavor corresponds. We imagine bringing this bottle out during a dinner party and treating it just as sacredly as a nice bottle of wine.