23 Gifts For That 1 Friend Who Is Creepily Obsessed With True Crime

Every editorial product is independently selected by our editors. If you buy something through our links, we may earn commission.

You know that friend you have who is always watching Investigation Discovery, fascinated by cults and serial killers, and generally obsessed with all things true crime? I know her, because she's me. And as creepy and weird as you might think that friend is, they still deserve a holiday gift. Scroll through to shop my expert picks now.

01
Serial Killer Playing Cards

Serial Killer Playing Cards

Liven up game night with this deck of Serial Killer playing cards ($20).

02
Wine and Crime Scoop-Neck Tee

Wine and Crime Scoop-Neck Tee

Let everyone know your hobbies with this Wine and True Crime Scoop-Neck Tee ($25 and up)

03
Gold Skull Necklace

Gold Skull Necklace

This pretty Kasun Skull Pendant ($292) is a subtle way to let people that you're into some dark stuff.

04
My Favorite Murder "Stay Sexy Don't Get Murdered" Enamel Pin
etsy.com

My Favorite Murder "Stay Sexy Don't Get Murdered" Enamel Pin

Fans of the My Favorite Murder podcast will love this "Stay Sexy Don't Get Murdered" enamel pin ($10)

05
19 Crimes Hard Chard
19crimes.com

19 Crimes Hard Chard

This 19 Crimes Hard Chard ($13) will make for a deadly dinner pairing.

06
Vintage Handstamped "Cereal Killer" Spoon

Vintage Handstamped "Cereal Killer" Spoon

Start your day the true crime way with this vintage handstamped "Cereal Killer" spoon ($16 and up)

07
I'll Be Gone in the Dark: One Woman's Obsessive Search for the Golden State Killer
amazon.com

I'll Be Gone in the Dark: One Woman's Obsessive Search for the Golden State Killer

One of the most gripping books I've read recently is the late Michelle McNamara's I'll Be Gone in the Dark: One Woman's Obsessive Search for the Golden State Killer ($15), which follows the hunt for an elusive serial rapist turned murderer who terrorized California in the '70s and '80s. The culprit was caught in April 2018, two years after McNamara's sudden death at age 46.

08
Cults 2020 Desk Calendar

Cults 2020 Desk Calendar

I'm adding this Cults desk calendar ($20) to my own list — who doesn't want to kick off each month with a little cult leader trivia?

09
True Crime Iron-On Patch

True Crime Iron-On Patch

Put your true crime-loving heart on your sleeve with this groovy iron-on patch ($6).

10
Zodax Apothecary Guild Black Dahlia Bell Jar Candle

Zodax Apothecary Guild Black Dahlia Bell Jar Candle

Give your home a dose of dark glamour thanks to this Zodax Apothecary Guild Black Dahlia Bell Jar Candle ($50).

11
Ceramic Mug
amazon.com

Ceramic Mug

Feel free to use this LookHUMAN True Crime Ceramic Mug ($12) for alcohol — we won't tell.

12
Helter Skelter: The True Story of the Manson Murders

Helter Skelter: The True Story of the Manson Murders

The holy grail of true crime novels, Helter Skelter: The True Story of the Manson Murders ($10) belongs on every true crime fan's bookshelf.

13
Nancy Drew Tote Bag
outofprint.com

Nancy Drew Tote Bag

Whether your pal is solving crimes or stalking her ex on Facebook, she'll want this sturdy tote bag ($20) to keep her receipts in one place.

15
The Big Book of Serial Killers

The Big Book of Serial Killers

A true encyclopedia of the world's worst people, The Big Book of Serial Killers ($18) is a thrill from start to finish.

16
Ted Bundy Execution Day T-Shirt

Ted Bundy Execution Day T-Shirt

Based on the shirts worn by crowds celebrating Ted Bundy's execution in 1989, this Ted Bundy Execution Day tee ($18 and up) makes for a darkly perfect present.

17
Sharon Tate: Recollection

Sharon Tate: Recollection

Written by her sister, Debra Tate, Sharon Tate: Recollection ($23) is a celebration of the late actress's life and career — as well as a gorgeous coffee table book.

18
Law & Order: The Complete Series DVD Box Set

Law & Order: The Complete Series DVD Box Set

Twenty seasons of the hit courtroom drama can be yours with this complete series DVD box set ($350).

19
Zodiac Letter Puzzle Print

Zodiac Letter Puzzle Print

Jazz up the wall (and maybe solve a decades-old case?) with this Zodiac Killer puzzle art print ($13 and up).

20
"Lock Your F*cking Door" Keychain

"Lock Your F*cking Door" Keychain

They'll never forget their keys again with this slightly threatening "Lock Your F*cking Door" keychain ($14).

22
Lampshade Card

Lampshade Card

This True Crime card ($5) will help you say it with feeling.

23
Alibi Shirt

Alibi Shirt

Your true crime-obsessed pal will appreciate this helpful Alibi long-sleeved t-shirt ($23)