9 Actresses Who Would Be Bewitching as Sabrina on Riverdale

After Riverdale's shocking season one finale, we are more than pumped for next season. Not only are things about to get even weirder and darker, but we are also anxious to see if comic-book fan-favorite Sabrina Spellman, whose hometown is right across the Sweetwater river, will finally come to town. While the series didn't suddenly become supernatural like we initially thought it would, showrunner Roberto Aguirre-Sacasa has said on many occasions that he's open to the possibility of bringing the teenage witch on board. Just in case he does decide to start casting, we've rounded up which actresses would be perfect for the role (aside from the OG Sabrina, Melissa Joan Hart).

01
Zendaya
Getty

Zendaya

No doubt Zendaya would bring some major sass to the role. And now that her Disney Channel show, K.C. Undercover, is over, she has more time on her hands for new projects. (You know, aside from more potential Spider-Man movies.)

02
Hailee Steinfeld
Getty

Hailee Steinfeld

Steinfeld has the perfect girl-next-door vibe for the lovable witch.

03
Amandla Stenberg
Getty

Amandla Stenberg

Stenberg is certainly no stranger to book-to-movie adaptations, having starred in The Hunger Games and the upcoming Everything, Everything, but we'd love to see her do a TV series.

04
Dakota Fanning
Getty

Dakota Fanning

Anyone else remember how scary Fanning was as Jane in the Twilight saga? We would love to see her sinister take on Sabrina.

05
Sofia Carson
Getty

Sofia Carson

Carson has already proven that she's rotten to the core with her role in Disney Channel's Descendants. And who better to play the teenage witch than the daughter of the Evil Queen?

06
Sabrina Carpenter
Getty

Sabrina Carpenter

Not only does she look the part, but she already has the character's name. Is that fate or what? She would definitely spunk up the Sabrina we all know and love.

07
China Anne McClain
Getty

China Anne McClain

After she played a music whiz on Disney Channel's A.N.T. Farm, we'd love to see her play a musically gifted Sabrina. Something tells us she and Josie would hit it off right away.

08
Janel Parrish
Getty

Janel Parrish

If her rendition of Sabrina is anything like her Pretty Little Liars character, then the town of Riverdale better watch its back.

09
Dove Cameron
Getty

Dove Cameron

Cameron is already a favorite among Riverdale fans, and it's not hard to tell why. Not only does she have some striking similarities to the character, but her character in Descendants is also the perfect amount of wicked and sweet.