How to Know When It's Time to Quit a Book, According to Avid Readers

The book community uses a handy acronym to describe giving up on a title: DNF, or "did not finish." For some readers, those three little letters carry a whole lot of baggage. Rather than risk sacrificing the satisfaction of fully finishing a read, the most persistent (read: stubborn) among us will slog through a 600-page novel where nothing happens to the bitter, boring end.

Reader, I'm here to tell you that you don't need to finish that book you hate. DNF-ing isn't a personal failure. Bailing on a book comes down to a simple truth: Leisure time is limited. Embracing the DNF lifestyle means you recognize the value of that time and choose not to waste it.

That said, the choice to quit on a book you took the time to track down isn't necessarily an easy one. You might be surprised to learn that some of the most pro-DNF readers around put serious thought into what books no longer deserve their continued attention. Whether it's the rule of thirds, the Nancy Pearl method, or just a gut feeling, everyone has their own unique DNF decision-making system. We tapped our POPSUGAR Book Club group members for an inside look into how some of the most voracious readers around decide it's time to move onto the next title. Read ahead, and release yourself from any book-quitting guilt while you're at it.

01
The Eye Roll Test
The Paley Center for Media via Giphy

The Eye Roll Test

"Is it taking me longer than normal to read this book? Am I rolling my eyes about what characters say or do? Do I care about the Chatsworth? Do I have other books to read? Move on. There are too many books that you'll enjoy to keep reading one you're not!" — Kari

02
The Nancy Pearl Method
SpongeBob SquarePants via Giphy

The Nancy Pearl Method

"I use the Nancy Pearl rule: 100 minus your age. That's how [many pages] a book has to grab you. So I give about 60 pages and then if I'm still not engaged, I let it go. Life is too short for boring books." — Jessica

03
Sweet Relief
Sesame Street via Giphy

Sweet Relief

"I try to give a book 50 pages, but [I've DNF'd in] as little as nine. I get physically antsy, and realize that I either don't like the characters or don't care enough about them to see what happens next. I don't miss them when they're gone and I'm relieved to get on to the next book." — Tamara

04
Claim Your DNF Power
Starz via Giphy

Claim Your DNF Power

"I think some women are so socialized to be receptive and positive all the time that it takes a nudge to realize they're even allowed to say, 'I don't like this book and I don't want to spend any more time with it.' It's empowering to take charge of your reading time. I might quit on page two if a book is just clearly not my thing. Nope! Moving on!" — Penny

05
So Many Books, So Little Time
Disney via Giphy

So Many Books, So Little Time

"I try to give it 100 pages because some of my favorite books start off slow. Until last year I would never even DNF because it gave me anxiety. But life is too short (and my to-read list is too long) to read bad books." — Ashley

06
The Reluctant DNF
Jersey Shore Family Vacation via Giphy

The Reluctant DNF

"I try not to do this, but eventually if I find myself thinking, 'What else could I be learning or doing with my time?' often enough, I stop." — Murphy

07
A Gut Sense
BET via Giphy

A Gut Sense

"I don't have a set time or page limit, it's more of a feeling. If I dread picking a book up or I think I've given it a fair chance and am still bored, it's time." — Jean

08
That Dreaded Feeling
Film Society of Lincoln Center via Giphy

That Dreaded Feeling

"For me, it's when I start to dread opening it. Or when I walk by it, look at it, and think, 'I need to read it, but I don't want to read it.'" — Heather

09
When the Mood Strikes
Bunim/Murray Productions via Giphy

When the Mood Strikes

"I will DNF a book after the first sentence or eighty percent through (and I have done both). Life is too short to read books I don't like." — Morgan

10
Try and Then (Briefly) Try Again
SpongeBob SquarePants via Giphy

Try and Then (Briefly) Try Again

"If a book hasn't 'sucked me in' within the first 75-100 pages (depending on the length of the book), I set it aside. If I don't feel compelled to pick it back up after a couple of days, I move on." — Cloi

11
The "Space Out" Test
CBC via Giphy

The "Space Out" Test

"Am I constantly spacing out and thinking of other things? Am I not engaging with the characters? Do I want to know where this story goes or am I good knowing what I know? I regularly read multiple books at a time, but if I get to the point where I really don't think I'll ever pick it up again, I'll just stop and call it quits. It's harder to do with books I own though. I try to read two-thirds of a book I bought." — Anamaria

12
Rule of Thirds
Netflix via Giphy

Rule of Thirds

"Usually [I decide] about 30 percent or 100 pages in. If I'm not enjoying it by then it's a DNF, earlier if there are problematic things in it." — Brianna

13
Just (Don't) Do It
Queen Sugar OWN via Giphy

Just (Don't) Do It

"If you're asking, it's time." — Adam

14
Literally Anything Else but This Book, Please
The Bachelor via Giphy

Literally Anything Else but This Book, Please

"For me, it was the feeling of being back in school and having to read the book no matter what. I found myself finding chores or work rather than reading. I have yet to regret DNF'ing the books, but I am most definitely confused as how one of them is a series that has continued to grow. I've kept them to the side. Maybe one day I'll go back." — Sally

15
Onto the Next
Ariana Grande via Giphy

Onto the Next

"I'm a pretty strict one audiobook, one "reading" book girl. When I'd rather listen to the radio than my book on my commute, it's a DNF on audio. When I pick up another book instead of reading what I've started, it's a DNF." — Kaitlyn

16
The Bad Writing Bail Out
Schitt's Creek via Giphy

The Bad Writing Bail Out

"Depends, [I'll give] really bad writing maybe one to two chapters. Unlikable characters, bad plot, [I'll give] 50-100 pages. I often come back to books, especially if I own them. I finally gave Les Miserables away after owning if for about 20 years and never getting to chapter four." — Audrea