The Best, Most Durable Black Tights You Can Buy, According to Reviews

Every editorial product is independently selected by our editors. If you buy something through our links, we may earn commission.

Groan — it happened. Before we had a chance to truly get accustomed to the whole idea of Fall and Winter weather, it was time to break out the tights again. And while we always try our hardest to switch things up color-wise, we know in our heart of hearts that the true hue for us will always be black. It's just the sleekest and the simplest, and it pairs well with a variety of different looks. A win all around.

But how can one tell a pair of quality tights from ones that'll rip the second they're slipped on? The reviews, of course, which we've already scanned to find the best options out there. Read on to see and shop the internet's best-rated pairs, then check out some outfit ideas that'll go great with your new legwear.

— Additional reporting by Samantha Sutton

Opaque

Opaque

The Tights: Commando Ultimate Opaque Tights ($36)

Why They're Great: Many customers agree that these tights are their go-to Winter footwear, especially when it comes to work. They'll keep legs warm and won't dig into your torso.

Review Highlight: "Commando tights are the only ones I've found that are actually comfortable. Instead of digging into your skin to stay up, they have swimsuit-like material that keeps them up without that binding feeling."

Sheer

Sheer

The Tights: Wolford Velvet DeLuxe Tights ($49)

Why They're Great: With sheer, you really risk some wear and tear, but in the case of these babies, extra money equals better quality — and they're "silky smooth."

Review Highlight: "The Wolford brand is great and made with quality. These particular tights fit just right and are really silky. I wore them on a date with a pair of black patent stilettos and they made my legs feel great. They can be worn just the same in a short skirt or in a business professional work place. The hips are fit just right, they won't ride up, and they don't bind. Spend the extra money and your legs will thank you!"

Drugstore

Drugstore

The Tights: No Nonsense NO Seamless Opaque Tights ($8)

Why They're Great: Even though they're cheap, these tights are great quality — and they don't have that annoying seam! Plus they're always handy when you're in a jam.

Review Highlight: "MY NEW FAVORITE HOSE!!! Absolutely amazing feel, fit, and finish. I will no longer be purchasing any other brand. I just hope that they continue to offer additional colors."

Figure Flattering

Figure Flattering

The Tights: Hue Super Opaque Control Top Tight ($14)

Why They're Great: If you're looking for a control-top pair of tights you won't be tugging at all day, you'll want to purchase these babies! Customers said they stayed put and were great for the office.

Review Highlight: "I've always been a fan of HUE tights, and these are no exception. They are good quality and comfortable and they stay up well without any sagging or bagging. I am 5'6" and 130 lbs and the size 2 fits perfectly, as I expected. I will be ordering more of these great tights! I also tried the HUE Women's Blackout Tights in size 2 and they were not nearly as good. Too big and weird, shiny material. Both were nicely opaque, but these Super Opaque Control Top Tights are better IMHO."

Cushioned

Cushioned

The Tights: Kushyfoot Microfiber Tights ($10)

Why They're Great: Foot cushions — need we say more? Anyone who wears heels surely will understand the need for this.

Review Highlight: "I have tried achy feet after working all day standing. I bought these tights to see if they would relieve some of the tension and I must say they are wonderful."

Fleece

Fleece

The Tights: Berkshire Cozy Hose Tights ($14)

Why They're Great: Dying to wear a dress or skirt in the midst of a snowstorm? These babies are your best bet — the fleece lining makes them just as warm as pants!

Review Highlight: "These are very thick tights — almost like a legging (but they are most definitely NOT a legging). If you live in a harsh winter climate and like to wear dresses to work, you absolutely need good tights. You really can't function without them. These are my essential tights on mornings that are barely above zero with wind chills dipping below zero. They keep my legs warm and stop the wind. They are much thicker than my other tights and wash and wear quite well. Check the sizing before you buy (duh!)."

Faux Thigh-Highs

Faux Thigh-Highs

The Tights: Spanx High-Waisted Luxe Leg Tights ($38)

Why They're Great: Wish you could wear thigh-highs, but can't stand the cold? These are your perfect solution — and they give off a slightly sexy vibe, too.

Review Highlight: "I love them! They control my tummy and yet look sexy on. They're very thick and the quality is great. I would by another pair in a different color."

Dotted

Dotted

The Tights: Ann Taylor Sheer Dot Tights ($20)

Why They're Great: Sometimes, a simple Winter outfit needs a little spicing up, and dotted tights are a great way to do that! They'll give LBDs and velvet dresses a feminine twist and show off your quirky side when mixed with other prints.

Review Highlight: "So trendy and flattering! When I wear these tights, I generally just wear a plain black dress so that the tights are the center of attention. I always get tons of compliments on them. I have had several women stop and ask me where I got them."