We Tried the New Girl Scouts S'more Cookies and You Definitely Have To

If you've anxiously awaited to hear if the two new Girl Scouts s'mores cookies are any good, the wait is over! The 100th annual Girl Scout cookie season has begun, and we received a few boxes of the new flavor to taste. In case you've forgotten, one is "a crispy graham cookie double dipped in a crème icing and enrobed in a chocolatey coating," and the other is "a crunchy graham sandwich cookie with a chocolate and marshmallow-y filling." When we asked our readers to choose a favorite, the poll results were split 50-50. So, how do the cookies fare IRL? Take a look!

The cookie sandwich nods to a s'more, though it tastes sort of like a golden Oreo with a filling that has a similar texture to the cream inside of an Oreo. The marshmallow-flavored filling bursts forth with a hint of chocolate (sort of like the chocolate glaze on a doughnut). Half of our tasters loved this cookie the most and can't wait to order a box.

★★★★☆

The chocolate-covered graham received stellar reviews, mostly because it tastes exactly like a Keebler fudge-covered graham cracker. Girl Scouts nailed the nostalgia on this particular cookie. While the marshmallow flavor is subtle, we didn't mind it! The melty chocolate paves way to a flaky graham cracker, and it's all you need.

★★★★☆

Ultimately, these two cookies tied, proving there's no better cookie, only two cookies for two preferences. Try them for yourself by using Girl Scouts' cookie locator to find your nearest cookie stand.