A Reese's stuffed with cookies sounds too good to be true, but rest assured, Reese's Crunchy Cookie Cups are 100 percent real. While the new candy isn't hitting store shelves until May, we got an early taste and can guarantee it's worth marking your calendars for. Just as the packaging promises, the cookie-stuffed Reese's are filled with tons of crunchy chocolate cookie pieces, which are reminiscent of the chocolate bits in Hershey's Cookies 'n' Creme Bars. Sort of like a combination of a chocolate chip and a cocoa cookie, the tiny, crunchy bits provide the perfect textural contrast to the otherwise soft Reese's cup. If we're being honest, we like these even more than Reese's stuffed with Reese's Pieces, which is saying a lot.
Reese's Crunchy Cookie Cups are available in a two-cup size ($1) and king two-cup Big Cup size ($2), and they just might replace your love of regular Reese's. While there are plenty of other contenders for the best new candy of 2017 so far, this one undoubtedly tops the list.