The Vow: What to Know About Consumers' Buyline, Keith Raniere's Scam Before NXIVM
Keith Raniere is widely known as being the leader of the controversial group NXIVM, but what you may not have known about was the pyramid schemes he also ran a few decades ago. The most prominent one was called Consumers' Buyline Inc. (aka CBI), and while HBO's The Vow touches on it a little bit, here are more details you might want to know about what it involved and how it all came crashing down.
Raniere originally founded Consumers' Buyline in 1990. The company was born as a recruitment scheme that promoted discounts on things like groceries or appliances. Raniere recruited members who then had to recruit more, all with the promise of massive commissions, according to Forbes. The company employed up to 150 people within a couple years and quickly amassed over 200,000 members. Raniere sold Consumers' Buyline similarly to how he sold people on NXIVM — with promises of results.
By the end of 1993, Forbes reports that Raniere was pulling in $19 a month from each new recruit and had sold over $1 billion in goods and services. But 1993 was also the year the company was investigated for being an alleged pyramid scheme. Raniere officially shut Consumers' Buyline down in 1996 but never admitted any wrongdoing. He was ordered to pay $40,000 after shutting down, but quickly set up another similar pyramid scheme the following year.
Raniere maintained, while under investigation, that Consumers' Buyline didn't require people to pay to sell memberships or earn commissions on the sales of those they recruited. However, the attorney general didn't agree. The ruling stated, "The emphasis in [Consumers' Buyline Inc.] is clearly not on the sale of a product but on recruiting new organizational rows to boost membership. Indeed, the only product in CBI is the membership . . . CBI is a classic pyramid scheme. The emphasis in CBI is clearly not on the sale of a product but on recruiting . . . to boost membership. Like all pyramids, CBI's matrix is destined to collapse."
After shuttering Consumers' Buyline, Raniere set up another multilevel marketing company. In 1998, he created NXIVM, which is arguably also a recruiting scam in its own right, though it was later revealed to be much darker than just a recruitment scam. NXIVM ultimately landed him in jail, and he is awaiting sentencing.