The return of Gilmore Girls to our TVs this month is probably the biggest pop culture gift of 2016, but for even the biggest of show fans, the reviews have been decidedly mixed. For as many tears were shed during Luke and Lorelai's wedding, just as many jaws were on the ground hearing the final four words, along with plenty of outrage. That's why it's time to cover the highs and lows of Gilmore Girls: A Year in the Life. We had a ton of initial reactions, but let's go over exactly why we felt blessed by Netflix and Amy Sherman-Palladino and why we're still scratching our heads.