The Way They Were: Lady Gaga and Christian Carino's Cutest Moments Together

Lady Gaga and Christian Carino have called it quits after two years together. After much speculation, Gaga's rep confirmed to People on Tuesday that the two ended their engagement. "It just didn't work out. Relationships sometimes end," a source told the outlet. "There's no long dramatic story." The couple first struck up a romance in early 2017 and got engaged over the Summer that same year. Gaga and Christian have yet to publicly address their split. Ahead, look back at the way they were.