How to Rock (and Remove!) Glitter Eye Makeup For New Year's Eve

Every editorial product is independently selected by our editors. If you buy something through our links, we may earn commission.

Our first thought when we saw the disco-worthy eye makeup backstage at Christian Siriano Spring 2015? "Oh, sparkly!" Makeup artist Polly Osmond applied holographic glitter to the lids and swiped on a custom shade of blue mascara (yes, she made her own mascara). This one will catch the light — and the eyes of an admirer — on the dance floor on New Year's Eve.

With the help of Francesca Roman at Butterfly Studio Salon in NYC, we re-created a similar makeup look that's easy to do at home. Discover the three products you need to make your own navy-blue mascara at home (a must know for brunettes everywhere). Plus the beauty hack of the century: how to remove glitter shadow without losing an eye.

Mix Your Glitter

Mix Your Glitter

To get a similar look to the holographic discs used on the Christian Siriano runway, we used a large glitter from the craft store mixed with MAC Reflects Purple Duo glitter ($21). While it's hard to find chunky cosmetic-grade glitter, it's better to use something with a circular shape so that the jagged edges won't injure your eyes (just take our word for it — it's painful). Contact lens wearers should be extracareful.

Prime Lids

Prime Lids

First you want to create a clean and even base for this glittery eye makeup look. Roman primed the lids with concealer (or you can use a nude shadow at home). Then cover the area from lash line to crease with Elizabeth Arden Eight Hour Cream ($21).

Apply Glitter

Apply Glitter

You don't need to use any tools to apply the glitter. Your finger is enough to grab the flecks, but you can also use a small ball of wax to pick up the tiny product and place them on your lids. Roman recommends staying away from the inner corners of the eye and tear duct (as a safety precaution).

Fine-Tune

Fine-Tune

You're sure to get glitter where you don't want it with this look, so use a dry mascara wand to get rid of any excess sparkle.

Add More Glitter

Add More Glitter

Keep layering on the glitter until you get the density you desire.

Make Your Own Mascara

Make Your Own Mascara

Now on to making that colored mascara! First, blend the dry MAC Pigment ($21) in Marine Ultra and Hi-Def Cyan on a piece of foil. Roman's bold blue hue used two parts of the bright cyan to one part of the darker navy color.

Dip a mascara wand saturated with MAC Prep + Primer Lash Primer ($17) in the powder and stir on a clean section of foil. Keep adding more powder until all the bristles are covered in blue. Apply to lashes the same as you would apply your favorite black mascara.

Apply Lipstick

Apply Lipstick

Although the lip was neutral on the Christian Siriano runway, Roman gave this look added oomph with a bubblegum-pink, glossy lip hue. She mixed three shades to get the perfect color: Kevyn Aucoin Matte Lip Color ($33) in Tenacious and Kevyn Aucoin Lip Gloss ($30) in Cloudaine and Janelline.

The Finished Look

The Finished Look

The Finished Look

The Finished Look

The Finished Look

The Finished Look

The Removal

The Removal

This is important: DO NOT remove glitter with soap and water. That is a sure way to get tiny product particles in your eyes. Instead use a piece of scotch tape to remove all the eye makeup. Just be sure to keep the sharp edges away from your sensitive retinas.