Shay Mitchell on What It's Really Like Having to Look Perfect on Instagram

"I love to play around with makeup, so sometimes people will comment on my will to try new trends or colors," Mitchell said. "I've gotten 'great lips!' on my favorite lip color from Buxom. They have a really great lip cream called Hot Toddy ($20) that I always keep in my bag. It's a natural lip color; it's just a little rosy."