Skip Nav
Spring
31 of the Best New Books You Should Read This Spring
Black Panther
Which Black Panther Character Are You?
Netflix
Bates Motel, Queer Eye, and 53 Other Exciting New Titles Hitting Netflix in February

Why Does Claire Flash Back to Boston on Outlander?

Here's What Claire's Boston Flashback Means to Outlander

Near the end of Outlander's season three finale, Claire is panicking in the aftermath of having just killed Geillis Duncan with a machete. Granted, she is doing it to save the lives of both young Ian and her daughter, but it's still a lot to deal with. While she shakes and struggles to catch her breath, Claire flashes back in her mind to a conversation she had in Boston with her friend and colleague Joe Abernathy. If that left you a little confused, we're here to help.

If you'll recall, back in episode five, "Freedom & Whiskey," as Claire prepares to go to Scotland so she can time travel and reunite with Jamie, she puts her affairs in order and says goodbye to Joe, who is really her only friend in Boston. He's consulting for a friend on a skeleton that was found in a cave in the Caribbean.

Joe describes the skeleton as being a full-grown woman, maybe in her late 40s. Claire picks up the skull and a shudder runs through her, then she says, "[Your friend] sent you over a 150-year-old murder victim."

ADVERTISEMENT

When Joe examines the neck bones, he confirms Claire's theory. "Somebody tried to cut this lady's head clean off, with a dull blade. How did you know?" he asks, but Claire doesn't really know how she knows.

Joe reveals that his friend thinks it might be a "secret slave burial," but he says this skeleton wasn't a slave because it belonged to a white woman. He can tell by the size of the tibia in relation to the femur, which is called "the Crural Index."

And then he and Claire go on to talk about her "man in Scotland," because he knows that's where she's going. There were some comments by fans and even some writers about their confusion regarding this scene, but the show writers didn't just invent it out of thin air. Author Diana Gabaldon loves to put in spooky little time-spanning connections, and she also loves to foreshadow death. This scene is straight out of the book.

There's one other little connection to Joe Abernathy that the show didn't really draw much attention to. Did you notice he has the same last name that Geillis had when she died? In the book, it is largely implied that Joe is a descendant of Ishmael, a slave who works in Geillis's kitchen at the Rose Hall plantation. There are numerous mentions in the book of times when Ishmael's voice reminds Claire of Joe; Ishmael is also a medicine-priest, and Joe goes on to be a medical doctor.

Back then, slaves were sometimes given their master's surname, so the book implies that Ishmael Abernathy is the many-times-great-grandfather of Joe. Just another little wink on the part of the author.

Image Source: Starz
Sam Heughan Pictures on Outlander
How Old Is Jaime on Outlander?
Caitriona Balfe Wearing Chanel at the 2018 Golden Globes
Shows Like Game of Thrones
Outlander Season 4 Trailer
Sam Heughan With Short Hair Pictures
Jamie and Claire Saving Each Other on Outlander
Historical Romance Books Like Outlander
Outlander Season 4 Details
Gifts For Outlander Fans
From Our Partners
Latest Entertainment
All the Latest From Ryan Reynolds