Bordreaux's Butt Paste
I'm pretty sure I've tried every single kind of diaper cream out there, but I always come back to Bourdreaux's Butt Paste ($15 for 16 ounces). I swear it's the only thing that worked for my daughter, and this might be weird, but I kind of love the smell. Get the big jar; you won't regret it!
— Kate Stahl, contributing editor