Skip Nav
Shopping
This Baby Monitor Has Over 15,000 5-Star Reviews on Amazon — and I Agree
Celebrity Families
All the Bachelor Contestants Who Went on to Have Kids — With or Without Their Final Rose
Toddlers
Bode Miller's Wife Speaks About Toddler's Death: "It's Been 37 Days Since I've Held My Baby Girl"

Court Forces Florida Mother to Let Son Get Circumcision

The Circumcision Case That Has Everyone Talking — Whose Side Are You On?

The bizarre case of a Florida mom who took her 4-year-old son into hiding to avoid circumcision came to an end last week, but the debate on the ruling is only beginning to reach a fever pitch.

That's because Heather Hironimus was forced to, through tears and while still in handcuffs, sign over consent to allow her child to undergo the procedure in exchange for her release from jail. After months in hiding, for fear that her ex-husband would force a circumcision over the boy's objection, she had to essentially sign away her right as a mother to protect her child.

Now questions — both medical and emotional — are being asked across the nation, namely: when does a medically unnecessary procedure become mandated by a court of law?

First, it's worth considering the procedure itself. While some of the more extreme detractors have long argued that circumcision is equivalent to genital mutilation, it's quite commonplace in the US. According to the World Health Organization, the overall male circumcision rate is between 76 and 92 percent. The WHO also noted its effectiveness in reducing the contraction of STDs, and the American Academy of Pediatrics has stated that "the health benefits of newborn male circumcision outweigh the risks." Still, the operative word there is "newborn." Circumcisions become more complicated the longer they are delayed. In fact, the CDC has shown that after a baby's first year, the potential for adverse events following the procedure is up to 20 percent higher than in infancy. As for Hironimus's son, who is nearing his fifth birthday, the risk factors continue to grow.

Next, the ethics at play are important to note. The parents agreed more than three years ago to circumcise their son, but patients — and parents of minor patients — often change their minds even hours before a procedure takes place. Is it in their right to do so here? There are parental rights, for certain, and parents should be allowed to raise their children according to their beliefs — which often becomes complicated amid divorce and shared custody. But the law states parents have no right to harm their children. If this boy doesn't want to be circumcised, is the court doing everything it can to protect him?

What do you think? Should Hironimus have been allowed to refuse consent, or was the judge correct in his decision that her son get circumcised? Vote in our poll, and share your thoughts in the comments below.

Image Source: Getty / Joe Raedle
From Our Partners
Essay About Kids Hearing Their Parents Fight
How to Keep Your Marriage Strong After Having a Baby
How to Sleep In With a Toddler
Things Tired Moms Do Every Day
Essay About My Son Wanting to Paint His Nails
Best iPad Apps For Toddlers
Mom Confiscates Kids' Devices Overnight
What to Know About Raising a Kid in Middle School
Why Dads Should Help With the Kids
Jennifer Lopez and Alex Rodriguez Blended Family Pictures
Essay About Celebrating Kids on Their Siblings' Birthday
Best Baby Monitor
From Our Partners
Latest Moms
All the Latest From Ryan Reynolds