Penn Badgley walked arm in arm with a mystery girl in NYC on Wednesday afternoon, sparking rumors of a new romance. Just last year, Penn had us wondering if he had rekindled his relationship with Zoë Kravitz; even though the two split last Summer, they caused speculation after showing plenty of PDA months later. It seems as though the couple had finally called it quits when Zoë emerged holding hands with DJ Noah Becker this past May, and now it seems like Penn's moved on, too. Outside of his personal life, Penn's latest film Cymbelline, which also stars Fifty Shades of Grey actress Dakota Johnson, is set to hit theaters later this year. In the meantime, he continues play shows with his band, Mother, and scarily remind people that he was, in fact, Gossip Girl. Keep scrolling to see the pictures of Penn and his possible new girlfriend in NYC.