10 Sephora Gift Ideas From Stocking Stuffers to Secret Santa Picks, All For Under $25

Updated on 10/12/2021 at 7:25 PM

As POPSUGAR editors, we independently select and write about stuff we love and think you'll like too. If you buy a product we have recommended, we may receive affiliate commission, which in turn supports our work.

So, you're making a list and checking it twice, but all of a sudden, you realize just how many people you need to be getting something for . . . and you freeze. Well, consider us your savior this season with these 10 beauty gift ideas from Sephora for anyone on your list. Bonus: the presents also come without a big spend — nothing's over $25.

Maybe you're doing a little exchange with your closest friends by mail or making a small Secret Santa scenario happen. These $25-or-less Sephora gifting ideas also make great stocking stuffers for beauty-lovers of any age, from a hard-to-impress teen to a new partner's mom. Of course, there's a little something for your beauty-obsessed BFF who could already teach a masterclass in makeup or for any pal who could use a little pick-me-up in 2021. Keep on reading to shop our selects.

— Additional reporting by Morgan Ashley Parker

A Masking Set: Origins Merry Masks Our 5 Best Mask Minis

Whatever their skin care concerns are, this Origins Merry Masks Our 5 Best Mask Minis ($20) can help. Plus, they're so tiny, they're great for traveling.

Origins Merry Masks Our 5 Best Mask Minis

From

$20

For the Lip Balm Obsessed: Laneige Midnight Minis Set

We know so many people who swear by the Laneige Lip Sleeping Mask. This Laneige Midnight Minis Set ($18) is for that person; it contains five fun flavors of the cult-favorite product.

Laneige Midnight Minis Set

From

$18

For the Hair Care Lover: Slip Skinny Scrunchies Twilight Bauble

Silk scrunchies are one of those little luxuries you might not buy for yourself, but will be so happy to receive. This Slip Skinny Scrunchies Twilight Bauble ($22) comes with four scrunchies, and they're skinny enough to blend into a ponytail.

Slip Skinny Scrunchies Twilight Bauble

From

$22

For the Eyebrow Guru: Benefit Cosmetics Merry ‘N Precise Ultra-Fine Brow Pencil Value Set

If you know someone that's obsessed with their eyebrows, they'll appreciate this Benefit Cosmetics Merry 'N Precise Ultra-Fine Brow Pencil Value Set ($24). Plus, it comes in the cutest packaging!

Benefit Cosmetics Merry 'N Precise Ultra-Fine Brow Pencil Value Set

From

$24

For the Self Care Lover: Peter Thomas Roth Pick Your Patch 12 Hydra-Gel Eye Patches

These Peter Thomas Roth Pick Your Patch 12 Hydra-Gel Eye Patches ($19) are for the person that is always tired, or needs a little moment for self-care. If you're lucky, maybe they'll share one with you?!

Peter Thomas Roth Pick Your Patch 12 Hydra-Gel Eye Patches

From

$19

For the Makeup Lover: BeautyBlender Single Scoop Blend & Store BeautyBlender Duo

Any makeup lover can sing the praises of their BeautyBlender. This BeautyBlender Single Scoop Blend & Store BeautyBlender Duo ($20) makes for an adorable stocking stuffer.

BeautyBlender Single Scoop Blend & Store BeautyBlender Duo

From

$20

For the Perfume Lover: Nest New York Perfume Oil Discovery Set

If they're always trying on new scents, they'll love this Nest New York Perfume Oil Discovery Set ($25). They can try all five to find their favorite, or even combine a few to create a signature scent.

Nest New York Perfume Oil Discovery Set

From

$25

A Little Luxurious Gift: Caudalie Moisturizing Hand Cream Trio

We're all washing our hands a lot, which means we need all the hand cream we can, pardon the pun, get our hands on. This Caudalie Moisturizing Hand Cream Trio ($15) is luxurious and easy to put into a purse.

Caudalie Moisturizing Hand Cream Trio

From

$15

For the Blush Lover: Rare Beauty Mini Soft Pinch Liquid Blush Trio

This Rare Beauty Mini Soft Pinch Liquid Blush Trio ($25) is such a cute set. It'll give them a peachy, post-vacation glow, even if they're in the middle of a snowstorm.

Rare Beauty Mini Soft Pinch Liquid Blush Trio

From

$25

For the Lip Lover: Pat McGrath Labs Mini Divine Rose Lip Set Trio

If they're obsessed with all things lip, they're going to be so excited to unwrap this Pat McGrath Labs Mini Divine Rose Lip Set Trio ($25). Aside from coming in the prettiest packaging, it's also a gorgeous universal pink.

Pat McGrath Labs Mini Divine Rose Lip Set Trio

From

$25