'90s Babies Will Flip For These Nostalgic Beauty Finds

There's a good chance that someone in your family (or even you!) still has this omnipresent pink and green tube. And according to Maybelline, the brand sells a tube of Great Lash ($6) every 1.7 seconds. The reliable formula creates a defined lash that isn't overly dramatic — perfect for a tween's first mascara application or veteran moms alike. Though we still revert to Great Lash for weekends and brunch, our taste in wands has gotten a little bolder over the years. Maybelline The Falsies Black Drama ($7) has a brush that hugs our fringe, allowing us to get to the base of our lashes and add multiple layers for a seriously striking stare.