Your Makeup Collection Is Incomplete Without These 11 Too Faced Classics

A neutral eye shadow palette is essential to every basic makeup collection, and this palette is the furthest thing from boring. The chocolate-bar tin comes with 16 shades of matte and shimmer browns and nudes to create a range of looks from a subtle bronzed lid to a dramatic smoky eye. Chocolate-lovers will get an extra kick out of this palette, as the potent pigments also smell like your favorite candy bar.

Too Faced Chocolate Bar Eye Shadow Palette ($49) — the members of the Sephora Beauty Insider Community can't get enough!