15 Incredible Beauty Products That Have Earned Their Ulta Beauty 5-Star Ratings

Many of the reviews for this mascara come from women swearing off all other formulas in the name of Maneater. Having tried the product ourselves, we think this bold statement is pretty reasonable. The brush grabs and coats every lash, leaving each one enviably lengthened, fattened, and curled. You can apply layer after layer without causing clumping or flaking.

Try it: Tarte Maneater Voluptuous Mascara ($23)