I Tried 12 Eyebrow Pencils to See Which Is the Best For Coarse Brows

I'm a sucker for any beauty product that smells like chocolate; and although I unfortunately couldn't bite into this pencil ($23), it was still pretty sweet. While I couldn't get my hands on any of the darker colors, I was pleasantly surprised with how well even the light Taupe color filled in my brows. The formula glides onto the brows smoothly and is perfect for everyday wear. It's infused with cocoa powder and cocoa butter, so if you start craving chocolate after using this pencil, don't blame us!