These 15 Top-Rated Mascaras Are Amazon Bestsellers for a Reason

Maybelline New York Colossal Longwear Waterproof Mascara ($15, originally $17)

This mascara has a giant fanned-out brush that delivers nothing but volume and lift. The clump-free and flake-resistant formula will lift every lash for that flirty, fluttery look. The formula is long-lasting and will make your lashes look thicker than they actually are.

Customer review: "Ok, I am actually really impressed with this mascara. Dries down fast, doesn't clump or flake, and appears to add a few millimeters to my lashes. No other mascara instantly defines my lashes so well."