These 15 Top-Rated Mascaras Are Amazon Bestsellers for a Reason

Maybelline New York Makeup Great Lash Washable Mascara ($5, originally $8)

This mascara is one of the most iconic mascaras on the market. It's been a fan favorite for a long time — we're talking generations. The buildable mascara lets you achieve fuller-looking lashes without looking spidery. It's perfect for that natural, lifted, and lengthened look. It's even good for those who wear contacts.

Customer review: "This is my favorite mascara because it's never clumpy when applying and doesn't dry up over a month or two. I like to brush my lashes a few times and achieve a nice, clean fan look. I started using this since I was 14, now I'm 31 and still fall back to this mascara."