The 10 Top-Rated Liquid Eyeliners on the Internet — Starting at $3

Product: Stila "Stay All Day" Waterproof Liquid Eyeliner ($22)

Customer Review: "I cannot overstate just how much I love this eyeliner . . . I usually buy drugstore makeup since I don't wear makeup very often, but I make an exception for this eyeliner because it is so dang good! I wear contacts so I am particularly picky about any eye makeup product that flakes or smudges off since it is such a pain. This eyeliner stays on all day and all night through sweaty dances, at shows, and even through early a.m. swim practice. This is the holy grail of eyeliner!"