How to Do Your Hair and Makeup to Land a 3rd Date According to Matchmakers

The tip: Pull some of your hair back.

"Unlike your dating app profile, your hair should not be overdone but more natural looking — brushed and well kept out of your face and eyes," Lewis said. "Down is always better for first impressions, but keep it out of your face with some strands pulled back into a pin or a half up."

But keep it easy breezy — no need for a fancy black-tie affair style here. "You don’t want to look like you have spent too much time on your hair when you meet your date in person," she added. "The 'I woke up like this' look is always more appealing."