Look for performance- and water-based products that last but won't cause skin issues. "There are so many options, textures, and bases to cover all your needs," Faller said. "If you're looking to steer clear of heavy cream-based products or grease paints, try Mehron's Professional Paradise Makeup AQ." This cake product is vegan and water-activated, and it comes in a variety of options, from individual pans to palettes of 30-plus shades. Plus, it includes ingredients like aloe leaf extract, avocado oil, cocoa butter, lemongrass, cucumber, vitamin E, and ginseng root to help soothe the skin.
For those with very sensitive skin, though, Herrmann suggests skipping Halloween makeup altogether for the aforementioned reason. "Stick to mineral-based makeup like BareMinerals or Jane Iredale because these are light and nonirritating."
